I'm a bad gay. After the Bush Administration took out an unsecured loan on my spiritual wellbeing in 2004, I really stopped caring about gay marriage. OK, well not that I stopped caring, as much as I stopped bothering to try to squeeze into a world where clearly I did not fit. I always thought I'd marry some day, and I always thought it would be to a woman (at least from the time when I kissed one). It was never contingent upon it actually being legal. I'm belligerent like that; call it whatever you want, just don't strip away her rights or her property or her integrity if, God forbid, anything ever kept me from being there to defend her. The fact that the gay-marriage movement picked up steam in the 90's, at least overseas, didn't really factor into what I had planned for the future (really, I'm just holding out for the warm, snappy blond; and then it's go-time).
So I never thought much about it one way or another until I heard the moral majority clamor in 2004 that gay marriage threatens the entire institution of marriage (to which my answer has always been: divorce threatens the institution of marriage). It became more personal after that, because I don't particularly enjoy being attacked. Really, I don't particularly enjoy being tolerated either.
I'm not a one-issue voter. I did vote for Obama, get chills during his acceptance speech, and cry when he reminded us that a new day was on the horizon; that it wasn't going to be easy, but it wasn't going to be impossible, either. I know he doesn't support gay-marriage, either.
When I emailed one of my friends November 5th to tell her only, "yes we can," she wrote back, "But how?" And said her wife was devastated. They were just married in California.
And I didn't know what to say. I think I said, as I always say, that everything would be OK, everything would work out; because I do believe that right will always prevail over wrong; that it is unjust to build a free society and then shut it down and take it back; that government has no right to tamper with a sacred covenant between two adults and God himself; that the world is changing, cultural barriers are diminishing, and ignorance is in retreat.
I do think, whether the Obama Administration takes up the cause or not, that America's cultural climate has changed, and gay marriage is just one of many inevitable changes; but change is a process. It must always start somewhere, and for the first time in many years, I feel like it's got a chance.
Later I thought about more about Joe Biden's answer to gay marriage during the Vice-Presidential debate when he agreed with Sarah Palin that although he did not support gay marriage, he did support equal rights. My inner mediator agreed that separate-but-equal was better than nothing at all. After the election, I thought about the long slow process of our nation's social progress, and realized that, historically, separate-but-equal was as much of a crock as don't-ask-don't-tell.
It doesn't exist. There is no separate but equal; the very process of separating requires favoring one group. If there was no 'favorite,' there would be no 'separate;' and that makes separate-but-equal a lie. And if we're going to raise people up, renew our vows with the principles that once made us a safe haven and a world power both, then we can't afford to lie – not to ourselves, and not to each other.
For the first time in many years, we have a leader who touting hope and calling on the strength of every individual to step-up and rebuild a nation whose character has been tarnished all over the world; who does not endorse scare tactics or muster anger to motivate change, but says simply, "We can do it," and that makes me feel like we can; and if I'm going to be part of the movement, then I'm going to hold him to his promise.
So, no, I'm not going to be part of a great social lie. If gay marriage were just about gays marrying I don't think I'd care, unfortunately; but I know it's not about that. Its social implications are much greater. Denying gays the right to marry indicates, globally, that we still separate, that we still give preferential treatment to some groups, and not others; that we still deny basic human rights to those people that we deem undesirable; that we still deem some people undesirable. It's the latter statement that is the most dangerous, because what makes a social group "undesirable" is arbitrary, subjective. It can change at any time; and whoever falls under the umbrella of that undesirable group is not subject to protection, support, or recognition. As a nation, we've already been there. Historically, we've supported slavery, we've looked the other way from Jim Crow; we've wiped out entire tribal nations and stripped them of their cultural traditions, land, and livelihoods; and we've shuttled Japanese Americans off to work camps in the desert because they shared historic ties with the nation that attacked Pearl Harbor; and we've apologized and taught our children how we committed atrocious misdeeds at the hands of innocent people, and warned them that history has taught us we should never go back. If we are true, then we must be true in both action and principle. We can't play favorites, and we can't support cultural discrimination for any reason, for any group.